Dissolve into Evergreens
I Got a Deal!!!
Enough of That
Everyone's Favorite Punching Bag
Let's Break a Deal
Lies of the Union
Keep in Mind
The Flaming Lips
The New Radicals
Death Cab for Cutie
Badly Drawn Boy
Coheed and Cambria
Atom Site Feed
Heretical Ideas » 100 YEARS OF AYN RAND
I completely missed that yesterday marked what would have been Ayn Rand’s 100th Anniversery.
I'll explain my contempt for Rand and her writings.
Years ago I was really into the progressive rock genre. I had an older brother that listened to "classic" rock and I was exposed to such bands as Rush, Genesis and ELP and through further exploration of the genre, bands like Dream Theater and Fates Warning. So it was that when the internet came into my life at the start of college one of the first things I did was sign up for a few email groups devoted to those bands.
It was through those email lists that I heard about the connection between Rush and Ayn Rand. I'd never even heard of Rand but many of the people there seemed to refer to her writings as inspirational. So I checked Atlas Shrugged out of the school library and began to read, prepared in every way to be enlightened. As I plodded through page after page of heavy handed rhetoric I began to see the appeal to many on the email lists. The "problem" with the world was that exceptional people like you and me were being held back by mindless bureaucracy, and the source of all mindlessness originated from government.
A understandable reaction to the heavyhanded mess of the Soviet Union. But so terribly blind to the other side of reality, that handing control over to the wealthy elites of a capitalist society will just create another variety of tyranny.
Objectivism in Rand's own words.
1. Reality exists as an objective absolute—facts are facts, independent of man's feelings, wishes, hopes or fears.
In my humble opinion its at number three that she jumps ship and starts to swim with the mermaids.
I started to see the appeal of her writings with the progressive rock crowd. I could see a strong parallel with the "Look how smart I am because I listen to complicated music! Everyone else is a mindless simpleton trapped in their own bad taste." and the concept of the "heroic figure" being held back by the government. I've seen the same mindset in some punk rockers that think that listening to poorly composed three chord screaming provides them with greater insight into the injustice of the world.
By gosh and by golly, I am the exceptional one destined to rise above the rest!
"Oh if only we could get the terrible evil government out of our way I could pursue the exceptional life I was destined to lead. I would have fame, fortune and success."
Of course it only stood to reason that if you were smart enough to be reading Rand then you were smart enough to rise above the masses and become one of the great ones. Its actually quite a compelling theme if you are prone to delusions of self-importance, and maybe feeling a little like people are trampling on you.
Read through this exerpt from Atlas Shrugged to see what I mean: "She stood, hands in pockets, coat collar raised, the wind beating her hair in strands across her face." Just like a superhero...
Ayn Rand on Apollo 11's launch:
Frustration is the leitmotif in the lives of most men, particularly today—the frustration of inarticulate desires, with no knowledge of the means to achieve them. In the sight and hearing of a crumbling world, Apollo 11 enacted the story of an audacious purpose, its execution, its triumph, and the means that achieved it—the story and the demonstration of man's highest potential.
Um yeah, a great event, but hardly the hallmark of Laissez-faire capitalism.
I suppose what upset me the most about Rand's writing were that even though she is right in assuming that individuals should be free, that we should use reason and not superstition to guide our lives and that the state should not control the economy, in the context of the times I was reading her books it seemed that the Dagny Taggerts and the John Galts of the world were the problem. The capitalists had won, and they had created giant buildings full of page shuffling cube dwellers. The reality does not change, there will always have to be people to actually do the work of society. As much as a society full of entrepenuerial titans sounds appealing, at the end of the day somebody has to do the labor required to make society function.
Still my favorite cartoon ever!
"Waitaminute - NOBODY remembered to bring along an inexhaustible labor force of ROBOTS???"
I couldn't help but think that the "great men" and the "heroic figures" turned out not to be the management types with whom she seemed so enamored. Worse still was the nearly cult-like devotion to her philosophy that arose during her life and after her death.
Go ahead, read through the The Ayn Rand Institute website
It is the value of his own time that the strong of the intellect transfers to the weak, letting them work on the jobs he discovered, while devoting his time to further discoveries. This is mutual trade to mutual advantage; the interests of the mind are one, no matter what the degree of intelligence, among men who desire to work and don't seek or expect the unearned. - Atlas Shrugged
And my favorite:
Anarchism is the most irrational, anti-intellectual notion ever spun by the concrete-bound, context-dropping, whim-worshiping fringe of the collectivist movement, where it properly belongs." - [Ayn Rand, "Brief Summary," The Objectivist, September 1971]
Comments: Post a Comment
Dissolve into Evergreens