Dissolve into Evergreens
This blog used to be about politics. Not so much anymore as I have worked through my fascination with that subject. It now seems appropriate that with a new president and the end of the Bush nightmare that I move on to new subjects that are more in line with my current interests. I may still occasionally express an opinion about political matters but for the most part I will be commenting on music, photography and personal observations. Thank you for reading.


Current Playlist

Top 100 in iTunes

juscuz's Last.fm Overall Artists 

Chart




Atom Site Feed

B4 d- t k s u- f i- o x-- e- l- c+

Blogarama


< ? Colorado Blogs # >

« - ? Blog Oklahoma * # + »
This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?
4.29.2003
 
Metaphor, Morality, and Politics, Or, Why Conservatives Have Left Liberals In the Dust

by George Lakoff

In conservative thought, self-reliance (a goal defined by Moral Strength) is achieved through the disciplined and unimpeded pursuit of self-interest. In metaphorical terms, the complex of strength metaphors defines the moral goal and Moral Self-Interest defines the means for achieving that goal. In moderate conservatism, the reverse is true. There maximizing self-interest is the goal and conservative values (defined by the strength complex) is the means. Thus, the difference between strict and moderate conservatism is a matter of priorities. Strict conservatives are moralistic, giving highest priority to the conservative moral metaphors and seeing the pursuit of self-interest as the natural means for achieving conservative moral values. Moderate conservatives are more pragmatic and less moralistic, seeing conservative moral values as the natural means to achieve the pragmatic end of maximizing self-interest.

Consider for a moment what a model citizen is from the point of view of this moral system. It is someone who, through self-discipline and the pursuit of self-interest, has become self-reliant. This means that rich people and successful corporations are model citizens from a conservative perspective. To encourage and reward such model citizens, conservatives support tax breaks for them and oppose environmental and other regulations that get in their way. After all, since large corporations are model citizens, we have nothing to fear from them.


Lakoff continues to amaze me with his clear and thoughtful analysis of metaphor as the driving force in our political inclinations. Do we support the politician that projects a Strict Father Model or one that embodies the Nurturant Parent? How does this explain the geographic distribution of support for these competing models? People in sparse contact, who enjoy their isolation from others place a high priority on their own self reliance, whereas people in large urban areas have learned to enjoy being in a constant state of community. When we speak of the bad character traits of the politicians we project our own moral metphor onto their behavior. When we expect people of different moral priorites to understand our criticisms we are being shortsighted. People in the "middle" do not abide by a strict model but may pick and choose between Strength and Nurturing.

The question we have to address is not how can we change people's moral perspective (though that should be a long term goal) but rather, in the short term, divorce the conservative politicians from their base by attacking their connections to the moral metaphor. This is accomplished by pointing out the failings that they exhibit in their own actions when compared to the Moral Ideal. In addition we can re-style our positions to encompass some of their moral themes.

Mary over at The Watch has more to say along these lines. Go read.


|

About Me

bruce
35 yr old
Married
Okie
Highlands Ranch
Denver
Colorado
Student
Recording Engineer
Gemini
Arrogant
Voted for Kerry
Voted for Obama
Scumbag
Narrow-minded
Liberal
Uncle
Smug
Hypocrite
Philosophical Type
Taken
Omicron Male
Feminist Friendly
22.3% Less Smart
Whacko
Rabbit



Any Box

email

Barack Obama Logo
Get Firefox!




Dissolve into Evergreens